A while ago I decided that I wanted a cheap e-reader that could display PDFs reasonably. That meant most e-ink displays were out (most screens were too small, and the larger ones were too expensive). Instead, I looked through the various cheap tablets that were available. Most had pretty low resolutions, but the Nook HD+ stood out as a potential solution since it had much better specs than any comparable tablets (probably it’s a loss leader for Barnes and Noble).

I’ve now owned mine for a few months. After trying a bunch of different syncing solutions and readers, I’ve mostly settled on PDF Reader/Moon+ for reading and Calibre/Calibre Companion library management.

Thoughts:

  • It’s reskinned with a highly crappy UI for no apparent reason. This makes common tasks (like changing which apps appear on the home screen) unreasonably difficult to someone used to standard Android.

  • Either the crappy UI is also un-optimized, or the Nook processor is really bad, but various drawing operations aren’t smooth at all.

  • I think this poor user experience causes me to read noticeably less than I would if I had a nicer reader (e.g. a Kindle), though I’m not sure.

  • Syncing ebooks between PC and Nook is non-trivial. I’ve been using Calibre’s wireless sync feature because OS X hates Android by default, but the wireless sync took a fair amount of fiddling to set up (specifically I think the Nook failed to auto-discover the sync server and I had to manually enter the IP).

  • I was expecting annotation to be easier on the Nook than on a Kindle (since it has a better keyboard and more responsive UI), but it’s not enough to cause me to actually use annotation. Then again, I was never a big annotator of paper books either.

  • Overall, I’m not sure this setup is better than a Kindle + reading textbooks on my computer.